Comment

Comment by ohthehugemanate

I cringed in anticipation of the HN comments on this one.

Cue the inevitable HN complaints that it's not perfect security, that you still have to trust your CPU manufacturer, that the app permissions are too invasive, that it uses phone numbers as identifiers, and that it runs on Google play services.

Pull your head out of the trees and look at the forest: humanity desperately needs privacy herd immunity, and you are taking the part of digital anti-vaxxer.

Signal is one of the best options available for privacy: thoughtfully architected by a leader in the field, reliable, with a good UI and reasonable adoption, and genuinely open source. People NEED an alternative to Facebook messenger, Facebook WhatsApp, closed source Viber and Telegram, and carrier SMS. By refusing to recommend this extremely good, strong contender, you are actively hurting the causes of privacy and open source. Stop being a digital anti-vaxxer.

If you have complaints, submit a PR or make a compatible fork. But stop discouraging people from protecting themselves.

Or alternatively: if you're going to be a digital anti-vaxxer, hit up Facebook, Google, or the NSA to see if they'll send you a paycheck for it. Because doing their jobs for free is just dumb.

Discussion

Live from the official Hacker News API

A modern reader for Hacker News · SvelteKit + Skeleton