i don't think you read carefully what i replied to so here's it again:
> The problem is that getting things into small individually testable components
> is literally anathema to the Pax/grsecurity model.
nowhere does this talk about what the patch looks like. it talks about "getting things into small individually testable components" being "literally anathema to the Pax/grsecurity model". i.e., that decomposing the monolithic patch into composable pieces is somehow against our development model whereas said monolithic patch was developed exactly this way (which means the reverse process would reproduce these 'testable components'). that argument (my statement) directly contradicts Jeff's so only one of them can be true and as the author of the code in question i know which one is what ;).
as for invasiveness, you're only stating the obvious that there're more and less complex pieces of code yet both kinds (well, all kinds in the complexity spectrum really) can make it into the kernel. that is, this argument cannot be used against incorporating grsec on its own.
> The problem is that getting things into small individually testable components > is literally anathema to the Pax/grsecurity model.
nowhere does this talk about what the patch looks like. it talks about "getting things into small individually testable components" being "literally anathema to the Pax/grsecurity model". i.e., that decomposing the monolithic patch into composable pieces is somehow against our development model whereas said monolithic patch was developed exactly this way (which means the reverse process would reproduce these 'testable components'). that argument (my statement) directly contradicts Jeff's so only one of them can be true and as the author of the code in question i know which one is what ;).
as for invasiveness, you're only stating the obvious that there're more and less complex pieces of code yet both kinds (well, all kinds in the complexity spectrum really) can make it into the kernel. that is, this argument cannot be used against incorporating grsec on its own.