The task given was to solve an equation and to show how it was solved. The student did exactly that. Their answer is obviously correct and they deserve full marks for it.
If you want them to complete a different task you should ask them to do a different task. Eg. The question could be "show a general method for solving equations of the form "x^3=n", where n is any real number". Punishing people for obeying your instructions is a great way to make them hate you. I'm not surprised so many people hate math when it's taught in this way.
If you want them to complete a different task you should ask them to do a different task. Eg. The question could be "show a general method for solving equations of the form "x^3=n", where n is any real number". Punishing people for obeying your instructions is a great way to make them hate you. I'm not surprised so many people hate math when it's taught in this way.