Comment

Comment by Freak_NL

Regardless of the merits of Signal, much of the criticism voiced in that article is nonetheless valid. Signal and other chat platforms employing the protocol are run as data-silos by design, using strongly identifying codes (phone numbers) as the required identifier — i.e., it is nearly impossible to create a throw-away account, because getting an anonymous phone number is no longer a practical possibility in a lot of (Western!) countries.

Whether or not such metadata is available to adversaries (either through OWS or gathered elsewhere) depends on who your adversaries are and whether or not a corporate entity can be trusted to be completely transparent about what kind of data they retain.

As for [0]; even if no relevant metadata is collected today by whoever owns the servers, nothing stops the party providing the service from doing so tomorrow.

parent Freak_NL 10 years ago

Discussion

Live from the official Hacker News API

A modern reader for Hacker News · SvelteKit + Skeleton