Comment

Comment by gjulianm

As a mathematician, and seeing what's on the article (and with no intention to downplay your achievements, which are impressive), that's not what I think of when I hear "advanced mathematics". Vectorial calculus and differential equations (ordinary, not partial) are basic courses in math degrees. For the things that the article explains, such as topology, group/ring theory, measure theory, functional analysis, etc (which are still nothing fancy that doesn't get reviewed in a degree, so not yet "advanced"), I think that self-learning is almost impossible unless you're near to a Terence Tao-level genius.

Here I talk from experience. I remember reading books on some of these subjects and understanding few things, without really getting a grasp of what they're talking about. A lot of times, the problem is that you don't know what is missing in your knowledge. You need a clear roadmap, you need relationships, you need to solve a lot of questions, you need to do exams and, most importantly, you need to test your knowledge. I cannot even count how many time I thought I understood some theorem only to do some exercise and see that I had absolutely no idea. Sometimes you notice yourself, sometimes you do it so bad that you don't even notice it is incorrect.

And, for these subjects, the material on the Internet starts to diminish and be less accessible (more oriented to professional mathematicians than to learners). Khan Academy does not have advanced courses, the definitions on Wolfram or Wikipedia are only useful if you have already a grasp of the subject (see for example https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Measure_(mathematics)#Definiti... - What is important? What are the critical aspects? Which are the subtle parts of the definition that you must read carefully?) and in Youtube you may find lectures, but usually they're like the books: you will be lucky if it's not a succession of theorems and definitions, and you still lack the possibility of checking and testing your knowledge.

So, while some parts of math can be learned independently, I don't think that advanced mathematics can be done. Myself, only after 5 years of mathematics I'm somehow comfortable to study subjects by myself, and it's still hard.

parent gjulianm 10 years ago

Discussion

Live from the official Hacker News API

A modern reader for Hacker News · SvelteKit + Skeleton