Comment by clinton_sf

Thought experiment: let's say that Apple doesn't know what the suspect in a law enforcement investigation is suspected of. If the request is between revealing the identity of a user from a particular IP address (which is probably easy for them to determine), or giving away (essentially) a master key to decrypt all iPhones, which would it comply with? I think it would have complied with revealing the identity of a user pretty much every time, even if the suspect was a terrorist, but not necessarily to give away the master key for all iPhones even if the suspect was an intellectual property pirate.