Comment

Comment by pdkl95

> It's proposing a way of accessing a USB device from a web browser.

> There isn't any remote access

If you don't see the contradiction between these two statements, I don't know how to help you.

Stop thinking of what this is supposed to do; it's the failure cases that are the problem. Good security design involves concepts like compartmentalization and defense-in-depth. Finding a browser exploit shouldn't also grant low level access to the USB buss.

> This is simply so web apps can get closer to native apps in functionality.

That's a terrible idea. Blurring the lines between a webpage and a native app simply teaches people to treat webpages as if they were a local app, when the should be learning to treat anything form the network as potentially hostile. If you don't have a clean separation between the remote UI and the local UI, you're creating the perfect situation for phishing attacks.

parent pdkl95 10 years ago

Discussion

Live from the official Hacker News API

A modern reader for Hacker News · SvelteKit + Skeleton