Comment

Comment by craftkiller

Alright, so I think you have 3 points here:

1. Uber has a track record of noncompliance

2. You don't want to invest in them because of #1

3. Enron also picked a fight with CPUC

So responding to each point:

1. True, and they probably should be fined for the late report, but as a public entity you can't go fining people exorbitant fees due to unrelated actions. For example, if I made some public bigoted remarks and then a police officer caught me littering they can't just go fining me 20x the normal fee because of what I said. CPUC should evaluate the fee solely on the basis of the infraction that caused the fine in the first place.

2. While I don't disagree with you, this is irrelevant to this discussion. Perhaps it belongs it its own comment thread?

3. This seems similarly irrelevant to this comment thread. A better comparison would be how much Enron got fined for a similar offense against the CPUC.

parent craftkiller 10 years ago

Discussion

Live from the official Hacker News API

A modern reader for Hacker News · SvelteKit + Skeleton