While I completely agree with the gist and point of the the article, the word "bullshittery" is a bit over-the-top.
I grew up in the suburbs of Detroit and in middle school and high school there was an abudance of shop classes; wood shop, metal shop, electronics, auto shop. In first-year wood shop, we started out with a little coping saw and a file and made golf tee holders and bird houses out of soft pine. After a while, our projects got bigger and we moved on to using stuff like planer and jigsaw. After we demonstrated proficiecy with those we moved on to more complex/dangerous tools like the lathe, table saw and drill presses. Stuff that could easily take a finger off, if you weren't careful.
Throwing someone unexperienced at a lathe or a bandsaw is simply _irresponsible_. I think that one need to learn the basics, to grasp the the mechanics, with simplier/less dangerous tool. However, one proficiency is gained there is a new class of tool available to a skilled craftsperson/professional.
Yes, its important to learn how to use a coping saw, but that doesn't make a table-saw "bullshit". Just a different class of tool, that could seriously hurt you if you don't know what you are doing.
I grew up in the suburbs of Detroit and in middle school and high school there was an abudance of shop classes; wood shop, metal shop, electronics, auto shop. In first-year wood shop, we started out with a little coping saw and a file and made golf tee holders and bird houses out of soft pine. After a while, our projects got bigger and we moved on to using stuff like planer and jigsaw. After we demonstrated proficiecy with those we moved on to more complex/dangerous tools like the lathe, table saw and drill presses. Stuff that could easily take a finger off, if you weren't careful.
Throwing someone unexperienced at a lathe or a bandsaw is simply _irresponsible_. I think that one need to learn the basics, to grasp the the mechanics, with simplier/less dangerous tool. However, one proficiency is gained there is a new class of tool available to a skilled craftsperson/professional.
Yes, its important to learn how to use a coping saw, but that doesn't make a table-saw "bullshit". Just a different class of tool, that could seriously hurt you if you don't know what you are doing.