They missed out on the biggest problem with roundabouts: Their worst-case traffic behavior is cancerous. If any single exit is blocked, entry traffic will become blocked in all directions. And if the road grid is dominated by roundabouts, the problem grows in all directions.
It's not a problem when traffic is just congestion. It's hardly a common problem at all. But when it is a problem, such as is the case with a traffic accident that blocks multiple lanes of traffic, it causes full-stop gridlock to grow outward to the point of full paralysis.
The worst traffic jam I have ever been in was not in NYC, Boston, Seattle, or San Francisco, but rather in Idaho Falls, Idaho on a normally empty country road that was running parallel to the road where a drunk driver caused an accident that blocked the roadway. That single accident caused me and hundreds of other cars to sit in the same spot for almost 4 hours.
It's not a problem when traffic is just congestion. It's hardly a common problem at all. But when it is a problem, such as is the case with a traffic accident that blocks multiple lanes of traffic, it causes full-stop gridlock to grow outward to the point of full paralysis.
The worst traffic jam I have ever been in was not in NYC, Boston, Seattle, or San Francisco, but rather in Idaho Falls, Idaho on a normally empty country road that was running parallel to the road where a drunk driver caused an accident that blocked the roadway. That single accident caused me and hundreds of other cars to sit in the same spot for almost 4 hours.